50 Best Non Diamond Engagement Rings To Rock An Alternative (2024)

If you’re looking for an engagement ring that is not a diamond, you’ve come to the right place.

Just because a diamond is the most conventional or popular choice doesn’t mean it’s the right one for you.

If you’re drawn towards non diamond engagement rings that reflect your personal style, go for it. The sparkle of a sapphire, the mesmerizing mirror-like quality of a moissanite, or the light-catching opal are all terrific alternatives to diamonds.

But you likely need specific examples of what kinds of alternative engagement rings are out there, or you wouldn’t still be on the hunt for the perfect ring. And we’re here to help you find it!

In this blog post, we’re sharing the best diamond alternative engagement rings Etsy has to offer. Their beautiful marketplace is glistening and gleaming full of handcrafted jewelry designers and experts in non diamond engagement rings.

In addition to their vast knowledge on the topic, these artists create with their hands: these aren’t made in a factory. So, when you shop Etsy for alternative engagement rings, you’ll be able to choose from various price points, styles, gemstones, and metal tones from exceptional makers.

Most of all, you’ll get a custom ring made just for you — all while supporting a small business instead of a big box chain. Win-win!

Let’s get started!

TABLE OF CONTENTS

In this post, we’ll cover:

• Can You Have a Non-Diamond Engagement Ring?
• Reasons to Choose an Alternative Stone
• What Is The Best Alternative to a Diamond?
• Best Non-Diamond Engagement Ring Ideas
• Where To Buy Alternative Engagement Rings

First, is it okay to NOT choose a diamond? Let’s discuss it.

Can You Have a Non-Diamond Engagement Ring?

Absolutely!

Choosing a non-traditional ring is just as lovely as a classic diamond stone.

It all comes down to your personal preference and style.

If you keep shopping for rings but you’re struggling to find a diamond style you like, maybe this is your sign: it’s time to look for an alternative.

There are endless options of beautiful, ethical, and affordable engagement rings without diamonds as the focal point, and, honestly, the trend is more popular now than ever.

Remember: the ring you choose should be your choice alone! You are the one who will be wearing it daily, so it ought to be a reflection of your relationship and your personal style. If that means a diamond doesn’t fit into the equation, that’s OK: not everyone has the same taste.

And wouldn’t it be boring for everyone to wear the same diamond ring? I think so!

The bottom line is this: it is perfectly acceptable to choose an engagement ring without a diamond. There’s no rule that states you have to wear a diamond engagement ring. :)

( ↑ back to top )

Reasons to Choose a Diamond Alternative

What are some reasons to get a non-diamond ring? In addition to ethics, there are two other reasons why couples buy non-diamond engagement rings. In this section, we’ll discuss these motives in depth.

Ethical

A non-diamond engagement ring is ethical and conflict-free; a gemstone makes a great alternative to a traditional diamond.

Affordability

Who wants to pay top dollar for a diamond if that isn’t the style you crave? In many cases, an alternative stone is more affordable than a diamond.

Style

Ah, style: perhaps the most popular reason why people choose an alternative to a diamond is simply based on looks; not everyone wants a diamond and that’s OK!

( ↑ back to top )

When you like how a diamond looks, but you still want a non-diamond option, what makes the best alternative? Let’s tackle that next.

What Makes The Best Diamond Alternative?

The stone you select for your ring is important, as it’s a reflection of your unique style. If you want a stone that shines as similarly to a diamond as possible, your best bet is a Moissanite. It is almost identical to the cut and clarity of a diamond. Other similar styles include Swarovski crystal, White Sapphire, Opal, and Topaz.

Now that you know why and what kinds of stones to look for, here are some examples.

Here are the best Etsy alternative engagement rings by independent artists who are totally rocking this non diamond engagement ring trend. Enjoy!

( ↑ back to top )

1. Trillion Cut Moissanite

This stunning moissanite ring sparkles and shines. It is handcrafted by Andrea Bonelli Jewelry.

2. Teal Sapphire Ring

This sapphire ring is exquisite. It is adorned by diamonds on the sides, but the stunning sapphire makes a gorgeous centerpiece all on its own. By DoozieJewelry.

3. Gold Ruby Ring

This vow-worthy ring is a great alternative to a diamond with a gorgeous ruby stone. By AmenBJewels.

4. Gold and Silver Labradorite Ring

A ring that is as big and bold as this one doesn’t need a diamond! This is one of the most popular alternatives: labradorite! It’s so pretty and echoes nature in its brilliant green color. By AndreaBonelliJewelry.

5. Emerald Alternative

Oooh, I love the way this one looks. It’s so rustic and unique! By TheAuraMuse.

6. Cushion-Cut Moissanite

This looks like a diamond, but it is an ethical diamond alternative: moissanite! You won’t be able to tell the difference; the sparkle says it all. This ring is beautifully designed by AndreaBonelliJewelry.

7. Peruvian Blue Opal Ring

Wow, this ethical alternative is made of Peruvian Blue Opal and is a stunning set, particularly when it pairs with the mountain-inspired band. Love this one! By TheAuraMuse.

8. Ethical Marquise Moissanite

Starting at this price point, this elegant marquise moissanite stone is a marvelous alternative to a diamond engagement ring. I love this style; the accompanying band is a perfect fit, too. By Andrea Bonelli Jewelry.

9. Emerald Engagement Ring

A yellow gold band sets the stage for this emerald to take center spotlight, set with baguette style emeralds in a row. Perfect. By Artemer.

10. Aquamarine Cluster Ring

A princess-cut cluster ring like this one features many sparkling aquamarine stones and black and grey diamonds set on an 18k solid gold engagement band. Lovely! By Artemer.

11. No Stone Engagement Ring

This elegant sundial-inspired ring features no stone: a row of diamonds lends plenty of sparkle, but there’s no need for a stone on this gorgeous minimalist ring. By Artemer.

12. Salt and Pepper Diamond Ring

While technically a diamond, this salt-and-pepper diamond ring is an ethical alternative to a classic stone. It is one of the best non diamond engagement rings which features a faceted salt and pepper diamond for a non-traditional look and feel. It’s also under $1000! By Belloring.

13. Marquise Cut Opal Ring

This stunning marquise-cut opal gemstone will make you forget you chose an alternative to diamonds! Check out the way it shines! By Capucinne.

14. Blue Sapphire Cluster Engagement Ring

Stunning! Choose this sparkly cluster of sapphires as an alternative to diamonds. By Capucinne.

15. Pearl

If you are dreaming of a pearl as an alternative to a diamond, you’ll love this large Keshi pearl engagement ring in lustrous 18k and 22k gold. Love. By Capucinne.

16. Moonstone

This is one of my favorite alternative engagement rings under 1000 dollars. It features a pretty moonstone as the center stone and a filigree bezel band. By MinimalVS.

17. Rutilated Quartz

This is a fantastic non-diamond engagement ring under $1000: it features kite shape with trendy rutilated quartz. Stylish! By MinimalVS.

18. Moonstone Wedding Ring Set

This elegant stacked set is one of the most popular non-diamond wedding rings on the market. It is handmade by Capucinne and features a spectacular stacking moonstone and diamond set. The rings can be worn stacked or separately.

19. Lab Created Diamond Halo Ring

For a diamond ring that is ethical and not mined, check out this lab created sparkler in a vintage-inspired halo setting. By PenelliBelle.

20. Tourmaline and Moonstone Ring

A three-stone style is a nice alternative to a traditional diamond ring. This one features tourmaline as the center stone and moonstone on its sides. By Capucinne.

21. Blue Teal Diamond Alternative

This ring is an actual diamond slice, but it features a unique teal green color. Love this one! By MinimalVS.

22. Rhombus-Shaped Kite Garnet Ring

Coming in at under 1000 dollars, this kite-shaped diamond alternative features a stunning garnet stone. It’s perfect, really. By MinimalVS.

23. Opal Ring Set

I’ve never seen quite a set like this: it takes non diamond engagement rings to an entirely new level! By MinimalVS.

24. Emerald Cut Black Onyx

This stylish black onyx stone is one of the most sought-after Etsy non diamond engagement rings of the moment. Is it the price, the ratings, or the style? I’m not sure, but I do know that black onyx is wildly popular at the moment and this is one stunning option. Get it at DreamcraftJewelry.

25. Pear-Shaped Blue Topaz Ring

This makes the perfect Something Blue for the bride who wants a ring without diamonds as its focal point. Love it! By AndreaBonelliJewelry.

26. Agate Stone

This moss agate stone is a stunning choice. By LucysFineJewelry.

27. Herkimer Diamond Ring

A herkimer diamond is not a diamond, but rather a quartz stone that makes a lovely alternative to diamonds. Don’t miss this one: its affordability and beauty is unmatched! By Frieda + Sophie.

28. Alexandrite Gemstone

This ring is inspired by the eclipse! What a unique engagement ring alternative. By MinimalVS.

29. Black Rutile Quartz

A stunning freeform ring! By Frieda + Sophie.

30. Unique Mossy Ring

This incredible moss ring features moss agate, one of the most popular trends of the moment. This is how you do a moss agate ring perfectly! By MinimalVS.

31. Crescent Moon and Star

This is one of the prettiest non diamond engagement rings Etsy has to offer! By GaiasCandy.

32. Raw Moonstone

This natural raw moonstone ring makes an exceptional alternative! Get it at JadedDesignNYC.

33. Aquamarine

Get this simple yet elegant aquamarine ring with an emerald-cut stone and 14k solid yellow gold band. Gorgeous! By Meltemsem.

34. Tanzanite Stone

This elegant tanzanite stone is a real show-stopper! Available at Capucinne.

35. Sunstone Ring Set

If you are inspired by the sunset, consider this twist on tradition with a sunstone and sapphire ring set. By MinimalVS.

36. Vintage Pear Alexandrite

If you love a vintage inspired ring, check out this pear-shaped alexandrite stone. It’s gorgeous! By Belloring on Etsy.

37. Garnet Engagement Ring

Gorgeous. This ring takes the spotlight without a diamond in sight! By Capucinne.

38. Peach Sapphire Engagement Ring

A stylish peach sapphire ring for the bride-to-be! Get it at MinimalVS.

39. Australian Opal

This stunning ring is a rare find and one-of-a-kind! Get it only at Capucinne.

40. Baguette Tourmaline Ring

Wow, this is a unique style and I love it! This baguette stone features tourmaline and an elegant trio of white diamonds and an 18k gold band. By MinimalVS.

41. Pear Morganite Crown Ring

This large morganite ring is a show-stopping non-diamond alternative. Love the way this looks with the crown of diamonds around it. By Capucinne.

42. Raw Aquamarine

By TheAuraMuse.

43. Garnet Engagement Ring

A beautiful garnet stone makes this one of my favorite non diamond wedding rings! I love the shape and simplicity of this ring. Perfection! By AndreaBonelliJewelry.

44. Baguette Aquamarine Stone

A stunning Something Blue for your engagement and happily ever after. By W2NJewelry.

45. Sapphire

A unique cut and stylish shape! By DoozieJewelry.

46. Moissanite Double Band Bezel

Love the double band style here! By DoozieJewelry.

47. Canopy Emerald Pave

For a truly unique look, choose this breathtaking emerald pave ring that really stands out! By Artemer.

48. Pear Shaped Moissanite

Vines, branches, and a sparkling pear-shaped moissanite makes this ring a memorable choice. By BywardJewelry.

49. White Pearl Ring

This is a classic take on a non diamond ring: a stunning, shimmering pearl. By BluWaterJewels.

50. Aquamarine Ring with Diamond Accents

And last but not least, this glistening aquamarine ring is a beautiful focal point, accented with diamonds on the sides. By BluWaterJewels.

( ↑ back to top )

Now that you’ve seen some stunning alternative ideas, here’s a list of where to buy alternative engagement rings.

Where to Buy Non Diamond Engagement Rings

→ Ready to pop the question or did you find the perfect ring for yourself? Buy it or shop more designs here.

Love what you see here? We made a shortlist to make shopping easy! Here’s a list of the shops listed in our round-up:

• AndreaBonelliJewelry
• DoozieJewelry
• AmenBJewels
• TheAuraMuse
• Artemer
• BelloRing
• Capucinne
• PenelliBelle
• MinimalVS
• DreamcraftJewelry
• LucysFineJewelry
• Frieda + Sophie
• GaiasCandy
• JadedDesignNYC
• Meltemsem
• W2NJewelry
• BywardJewelry
• BluWaterJewels

This is a sponsored post with Etsy.